• About
  • Contcat Us
  • Privacy Policy
Sunday, May 28, 2023
Primenews.com.gh
No Result
View All Result
  • HomePage
  • Ghana News
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • HomePage
  • Ghana News
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
Primenews.com.gh Logo
No Result
View All Result
Home general news

A statement on the Agyapa Royalties transaction

by Mutala Yakubu
2020-08-27
in general news
A statement on the Agyapa Royalties transaction
125
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsApp

We have each been involved in the Ghana mining sector for almost four decades, including participating in critical reforms of its regulatory regime.

We are gravely concerned about the transaction by which 75.6% of royalties payable to government over the life of a number of mining operations are being assigned to a Jersey incorporated company and its Ghanaian affiliate. While the Jersey company will initially be owned a hundred per cent by a Government entity, the object, reportedly, is to sell just under half of its shares for US$500 million.

We appreciate that expressing our views on this transaction at this time is likely to feed into the mill of party political partisanship. However, we cannot for that reason disable ourselves from speaking, given the potential implications the transaction has for national revenue far into the future. From all the information available to us, it is hard to overcome the apprehension that were the transaction to go ahead on its current terms, the royalty rights (including from stable, established producing mines) would be given up at a gross undervalue.

READ ALSO

Newspapers headlines: Wednesday, May 24, 2023

BoG maintains policy rate at 29.5%

If we were to assume that gold prices will drop from the current US$1900+ an ounce  to, let us say, US$1500 for the period 2020 to 2023, on current production projections the royalty revenues from just the eleven existing producing mines for those four years that would be transferred to the Agyapa companies under this transaction would, in 2020 money, be more than US$1 billion. This does not include future royalties from mines coming onstream imminently such as those at Obuasi and the highly promising Namdini mine, near Bolgatanga. Nor does it include post-2023 projected production of the eleven mines.

The right to royalties is being assigned to Agyapa in respect of at least fifteen mines or prospective mines, including all the existing, established mines, effectively for an indefinite future. The agreements say that Agyapa’s rights continue not only for the duration of any leases granted to the mining companies, but also for as long as their leases are renewed. The maximum duration of a mining lease is thirty years. The grant of a right to those royalties for that duration is in itself a substantial right. A right to royalties not only for the original term but also for every extended period upon renewal of a mining lease is even more substantial. In these circumstances, it is hard to see the basis on which these rights have been valued at US1 billion as the agreements clearly state.

The royalty rate payable by each mining company is known. What gold price projections did the Government’s advisers use to determine their valuation? What projections of the quantities mines included in the list would produce and over what period were used in arriving at the US$1 billion valuation?

We cannot see that there is any reason to rush to implement the transaction by the end of this year as is targeted in the relevant documents.

What the Government reportedly expects to get from the sale of shares in the Jersey company is US$500 million. At an average gold price of US$1800 an ounce, the Government would get more than US$400 million in 2021 if it kept its right to receive all the royalties from the eleven producing mines. There is no reason why in order to get US$500 million now, we should rush into this transaction at the risk of losing substantial future income.

If the purpose of the transaction is to stabilise Government income, how does converting a direct right to receive royalty from mining companies into a right to receive dividends, if and when declared, from a company to whom the miners pay the royalty achieve that?

In our view, it would be in everybody’s interest for the Minister of Finance to freeze the implementation of this transaction. This would have the effect of taking the discussion outside the election cycle and give more opportunity for it to be considered openly and dispassionately.

ADVERTISEMENT

We attach a chart, a set of tables and notes to offer further explanation and elaboration.

SELECT GHANA GOLD PRODUCING COMPANIES WITH STABLE OPERATIONS (11 COMPANIES):

Table 1: PROJECTED YEARLY ROYALTY AMOUNTS PAYABLE BY ELEVEN PRODUCING COMPANIES TO GOVERNMENT

Notes on the computations:

  1. The Newmont and Goldfields groups on the average produce about 60% of the total yearly gold production shown. The two groups pay royalties at the rate of 3.5% at gold prices of US$1,300/oz and US$1,400/oz and 4% at gold prices of US$1,500/oz, US$1,600/oz, US$1,700/oz, US$1,800/oz, US$1,900/oz and US$2,000/oz. All other producing companies in the list pay a 5% royalty rate at all gold prices.

Therefore, the weighted average of royalty rates that should be applicable to the total yearly productions are as follows:

  1. For gold prices of US$1,300/oz and US$1,400/oz the weighted average royalty rate is:
  • 60*(3.5%) + 0.40*(5%) = 4.10%
  1. For gold prices of US$1,500/oz, US$1,600/oz, US$1,700/oz, US$1,800/oz, US$1,900/oz and US$2,000/oz the weighted average royalty rate is:
  • 60*(4%) + 0.40*(5%) = 4.40%
  1. The Royalty amount is:
  • Royalty Rate * Gross Gold Revenue = Royalty Rate * Price * Volume(oz)
  1. The Royalty amounts for gold prices of US$1,300/oz, US$1,400/oz, US$1,500/oz, US$1,600/oz, US$1,700/oz, US$1,800/oz, US$1,900/oz and US$2,000/oz are shown in Table 1.

Table 1: Projected Yearly Royalty Amounts Payable by Eleven Producing Companies

Royalty Amounts at Different Gold Prices (US$ Million)
YearTotal Production (Million oz)US$1,300/ozUS$1,400/ozUS$1,500/ozUS$1,600/ozUS$1,700/ozUS$1,800/ozUS$1,900/ozUS$2,000/oz
2020                 5.05             269.17             289.87             333.30             355.52             377.74               399.96                   422.18               444.40
2021                 5.25             279.83             301.35             346.50             369.60             392.70               415.80                   438.90               462.00
2022                 5.46             291.02             313.40             360.36             384.38             408.41               432.43                   456.46               480.48
2023                 5.60             298.48             321.44             369.60             394.24             418.88               443.52                   468.16               492.80
NOTE
a) a) For gold prices of US$1,300/oz and US$1,400/oz the weighted average royalty rate is 4.1%
b) For gold prices of US$1,500/oz, US$1,600/oz, US$1,700/oz, US$1,800/oz, US$1,900/oz and US$2,000/oz the weighted average royalty rate is 4.40%
Table 2: AMOUNTS TO BE ASSIGNED TO AGYAPA
  1. 6% of all Government’s total royalty amounts is to be assigned to Agyapa.

Table 2:

Assigned Amounts to Agyapa (US$ Million)
YearUS$1,300/ozUS$1,400/ozUS$1,500/ozUS$1,600/ozUS$1,700/ozUS$1,800/ozUS$1,900/ozUS$2,000/oz
2020                          203.49             219.14             251.97             268.77             285.57             302.37               319.17                   335.97
2021                          211.55             227.82             261.95             279.42             296.88             314.34               331.81                   349.27
2022                          220.01             236.93             272.43             290.59             308.76             326.92               345.08                   363.24
2023                          225.65             243.01             279.42             298.05             316.67             335.30               353.93                   372.56
PV @ 2020 @ 3% Discount                          822.69             885.97         1,018.71         1,086.63         1,154.54         1,222.45           1,290.37               1,358.28
PV @ 2020 @ 5% Discount                          799.51             861.01             990.01         1,056.01         1,122.02         1,188.02           1,254.02               1,320.02

Source: thebftonline.com

Tags: Agyapa RoyaltiesGhana mining sector
ShareTweetSend
Previous Post

Ghana selected for CAF & UEFA Assist League Development Pilot Programme

Next Post

Ghana to act as scrutineer for 70th FIFA Congress

Related Posts

Newspapers headlines: Monday, May 22, 2023
general news

Newspapers headlines: Wednesday, May 24, 2023

2023-05-24
BoG maintains policy rate at 29.5%
general news

BoG maintains policy rate at 29.5%

2023-05-23
Sammi Awuku
general news

NLA boss Sammi Awuku adjudged best public sector CEO

2023-05-23
WhatsApp to allow users to edit messages within 15 minutes
general news

WhatsApp to allow users to edit messages within 15 minutes

2023-05-23
Newspapers headlines: Monday, May 22, 2023
general news

Newspapers headlines: Tuesday, May 23, 2023

2023-05-23
Gov’t misses GHS 2.7bn auction target by GHS 5m
general news

Gov’t misses GHS 2.7bn auction target by GHS 5m

2023-05-22
Next Post
Prosper Harrison Addo

Ghana to act as scrutineer for 70th FIFA Congress

Cool Boii releases “Sounds from the Sun” EP

Cool Boii releases “Sounds from the Sun” EP

ADVERTISEMENT

TRENDING NEWS IN GHANA

Inter beat Fiorentina to win Coppa Italia

Inter beat Fiorentina to win Coppa Italia

2023-05-25
Newspapers headlines: Monday, May 22, 2023

Newspapers headlines: Wednesday, May 24, 2023

2023-05-24
Juventus handed 10-point deduction amid transfer dealings case

U-23 AFCON: Black Meteors coach Ibrahim Tanko invites 22 players for camping in Prampram

2023-05-23
BoG maintains policy rate at 29.5%

BoG maintains policy rate at 29.5%

2023-05-23
Juventus handed 10-point deduction amid transfer dealings case

Kotoko moves into top-four with Kotoku Royals win

2023-05-23
Juventus handed 10-point deduction amid transfer dealings case

Juventus handed 10-point deduction amid transfer dealings case

2023-05-23
Sammi Awuku

NLA boss Sammi Awuku adjudged best public sector CEO

2023-05-23
Meta: Facebook owner fined €1.2bn for mishandling data

Meta: Facebook owner fined €1.2bn for mishandling data

2023-05-23
WhatsApp to allow users to edit messages within 15 minutes

By-election: Kumawu elects new MP today

2023-05-23
Newcastle secure top-four finish with Leicester draw

Newcastle secure top-four finish with Leicester draw

2023-05-23
ADVERTISEMENT

Must Reads

NLA boss Sammi Awuku adjudged best public sector CEO

Meta: Facebook owner fined €1.2bn for mishandling data

By-election: Kumawu elects new MP today

Newcastle secure top-four finish with Leicester draw

Ray Stevenson: Thor and Star Wars actor dies aged 58

About

A Prime Network Limited Website.

Follow us

No Result
View All Result
  • HomePage
  • Ghana News
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Sports

©2015 - 2020 Primenews.com.gh

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.